home
RSS
Are sugar substitutes worse than the real thing?
April 27th, 2012
07:21 AM ET

Are sugar substitutes worse than the real thing?

Sweet tooth? You’re not alone. Sugary foods and beverages are delicious. But we’ve also learned they can be highly addictive and, too much of them, can take a serious toll on our health.

Today some of our favorite drinks, gum, baked goods, and candy are available in sugar-free versions. But that got me thinking...  are sugar substitutes any better for you than the real thing? I was not alone on this issue. I’ve received dozens of tweets and emails wondering if fake sugar can harm us, or worse, crave more food!

For some answers I turned to internist and physician nutrition specialist, Dr. Melina Jampolis. Her specialty is practiced by only 200 physicians in the United States. She focuses exclusively on nutrition for weight loss and disease prevention and treatment.

  • CNN: First of all – are all sugar substitutes pretty much the same?

Dr. Jampolis: It is important to understand that there are both natural and artificial substitutes. Most of the concerns people have are around the five FDA-approved artificial sweeteners: Acesulfame potassium (Sunett, Sweet One), Aspartame (Equal, NutraSweet), Neotame, Saccharin (SugarTwin, Sweet'N Low), and Sucralose (Splenda).

But it is important to point out that these sweeteners are all different. They all have different chemical make-ups and they are handled differently in the body - some are completely broken down, some are not. So you can’t just lump them into one thing if you do have concerns about them.

  • CNN: How are natural sweeteners – like stevia - different? And are they a healthier option compared to artificial sweeteners?

Dr. Jampolis: Stevia is a natural sweetener from South America that has no calories but is 250 times sweeter than sugar.  It has seen a huge surge in popularity since its clearance as GRAS (generally regarded as safe) as a food additive in 2008.  Stevia has been proven safe and effective by the FDA. Many nutrition experts prefer it since it is natural, but just because something is natural does not always mean that it is safer. I tell my patients that if you prefer the taste of a natural sweetener, then I think it is a very good option but there isn’t evidence that it is a healthier option compared to artificial sweeteners.

  • CNN: There is always a lot of buzz linking sugar substitutes and cancer. Is there any reason for people to be worried?

Dr. Jampolis: The studies that I have seen, and the studies the National Cancer Institute have reviewed, all point to the fact that in humans there is no compelling evidence. It is really more of just a few animal studies. In the 1960s there was a study of saccharin in rats, which found an increase in bladder cancer and caused a great deal of fear. However, it was later found that the mechanism by which it caused cancer in rats was not even possible in humans. Animal studies do not always reflect human response and saccharin is a great example of this. Aspartame is also often anecdotally linked to brain disorders based on small animal studies, but human studies have not shown an association. I think that at this point, we don’t have convincing research. It is more hype and really just a little bit blown out of proportion.

  • CNN: I’ve also heard that sugar-free foods and drinks can make you crave more food and calories. It sort of tricks your body. Any truth to that?

Dr. Jampolis: This is an interesting question which has not been answered definitely.  The taste of sweet does cause the release of insulin, which lowers blood sugar , and if carbohydrates are not consumed,  it causes a drop in blood sugar which triggers hunger and cravings for sugar.  So if an artificial sweetener is consumed alone, it could theoretically increase hunger.  However in the context of a meal, it is not known if it causes an increase in hunger and if so, it's not known if this outweighs the decrease in calories consumed. We know that some artificial sweeteners do cause a release of insulin which could drop your blood sugar and make you crave more sugar actually. And they also seem to trigger the same addition like pathways in the brain.

  • CNN: Okay - so would I be better off eating one small piece of candy made with real sugar, or a larger portion that is sugar-free?

Dr. Jampolis: Honestly I don’t think there is a correct answer.  In my opinion, if you consume it after a meal (not on an empty stomach), I would go by preference.  If you really enjoy a piece of chocolate with real sugar, having a small amount is fine. If you like the taste of sugar-free cherry candy, that’s OK.  As long as we consume things in moderation, I don’t think either option is harmful.

When we start talking about beverages (soda versus diet soda) it becomes more of an issue. Sugar-sweetened beverages can contribute hundreds of extra calories to the diet that we don’t fully compensate for. And many experts, including myself, feel that it significantly contributes to weight gain, especially metabolically toxic weight gain and metabolic abnormalities.

  • CNN: I remember a study a few years back that found people who drink diet soda tend to weigh more than people who don’t.  Why do you think that is?

Dr. Jampolis:  A lot of studies show that diet soda is linked with being overweight but there isn’t a clear answer as to why. Is it because they drink diet soda that they are overweight? Or is it because it actually causes weight gain? We all know people who drink diet sodas all day long, but then go home in the evening and have a large serving of ice cream. However, there is some evidence suggesting an increased risk of metabolic syndrome with diet soda intake. So I think the best advice is probably to limit both regular and diet soda consumption for optimal health, especially with children.

  • CNN: Bottom line: if I want to cut down my sugar consumption, are sugar substitutes a safe option for me?

Dr. Jampolis:  I don’t think that they are a good idea for children since we don’t fully understand the potential metabolic/programming effects. If there is even the possibility of an increased risk of any disease, a lifetime of exposure would increase that risk.

In adults, I think they can be safely consumed in moderation if you are diabetic and are trying to reduce sugar and/or trying to lose weight and reducing caloric intake as they help reduce the calorie density of foods - which is one of the most important components of permanent weight loss. If you feel like you are dependent on sugar, I suggest limiting consumption, particularly in beverages, as the high intensity of their sweetness could contribute to dependency.

In general, I like to see people trying to decrease the overall sweetness of their diet over time – adding fresh fruit to water instead of sugar-sweetened beverages or substituting things like applesauce for some of the sugar in baked goods can boost nutrients while reducing calories and sugar. I don’t recommend using "healthier-sounding" alternatives to sugar - like honey - unless you prefer the taste, as they contain the same amount of sugar as table sugar.



soundoff (236 Responses)
  1. Maybelle Doloris

    Les affaires sont les affaires. https://www.cialis20.fr

    December 6, 2019 at 05:16 | Report abuse | Reply
  2. Yoko Angilello

    First offFirst of all I want toI would like to say greatawesometerrificsuperbwonderfulfantasticexcellent blog! I had a quick question thatin whichwhich I'd like to ask if you don'tif you do not mind. I was curiousinterested to knowto find out how you center yourself and clear your mindyour thoughtsyour head beforeprior to writing. I haveI've had a hard timea tough timea difficult timetroubledifficulty clearing my mindthoughts in getting my thoughtsideas outout there. I doI truly do enjoytake pleasure in writing but ithowever it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes areare generallyare usuallytend to be wastedlost justsimply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any suggestionsideasrecommendations or tipshints? ThanksKudosAppreciate itCheersThank youMany thanks!

    https://xabar018.dreamwidth.org/profile

    August 21, 2020 at 14:44 | Report abuse | Reply
  3. detectives privados huesca

    detectives privados castilla de la mancha

    https://www.argadetectives.com/detectives-orihuela.html

    December 10, 2020 at 19:57 | Report abuse | Reply
  4. bitcoin to paypal

    Transfer from bitcoin to paypal very fast and low cost.

    https://exchanger24.org/xchange_btc_to_ppusd/

    December 15, 2020 at 20:21 | Report abuse | Reply
  5. Johana Gladin

    먹튀사이트, 먹튀검증 먹튀사이트 먹튀폴리스입니다.먹튀폴리스는 신규는 물론 오픈된 먹튀사이트를 철저히 먹튀검증하여 먹튀없는 시대를만들어가고 있습니다. 먹튀폴리스를 사랑하는여러분의 많은 호응바랍니다. 여러분의 충실한 검증사이트가 되도록 노력하겠습니다.

    http://www.X7wFVYZgcs.com/X7wFVYZgcs

    December 25, 2020 at 08:23 | Report abuse | Reply
  6. Jarred Sagastegui

    https://www.electricpercolatorcoffeepot.com/10-top-coffee-bloggers/

    January 10, 2021 at 05:20 | Report abuse | Reply
  7. Marlon Sleigh

    Excellent website. Plenty of useful information here. I am sending it to a few pals ans also sharing in delicious. And obviously, thanks on your sweat!

    https://www.electricpercolatorcoffeepot.com/10-top-coffee-bloggers/

    January 21, 2021 at 03:54 | Report abuse | Reply
  8. Elliot Bougie

    Do you want get more social network traffic, likes, and retweets? SMM Supreme uses his own panel system to generate social media traffic to any website. Best Quality-Price Ratio on the market with 714928 orders until now. – Facebook Fan Page Likes: $4.50/1000 – Instagram Followers: $0.78/1000 – Youtube Views: $1.62/1000 – Twitter followers: $2.10/1000 – Paypal Deposit – Payeer Deposit – Automatic order processing – 30 minutes to send to customers

    https://bit.ly/2Hnl7vE

    January 28, 2021 at 00:52 | Report abuse | Reply
  9. vuasongbac

    Nice recipe

    https://www.google.la/url?q=https://www.vuasongbac.com.com

    February 7, 2021 at 02:22 | Report abuse | Reply
  10. vuasongbac

    Nice recipe

    https://images.google.si/url?q=https://www.vuasongbac.com

    February 8, 2021 at 10:42 | Report abuse | Reply
  11. thesufitrader

    Great work

    https://images.google.fr/url?q=https://www.thesufitrader.com

    February 8, 2021 at 10:58 | Report abuse | Reply
  12. Lavelle Swartwout

    "I SWEAR TO GOD..." – He yelled "IF YOU DON'T GIVE MY GRANDMOTHER BACK HER MONEY, I'M GOING TO JUMP THROUGH THE PHONE AND RIP..." That's how the "Grandma Video" starts off. Have you seen it yet? It's AWESOME! It starts off with this average guy (Jason), calling a "Guru" on the phone and YELLING at him. What happened next? Well, you're going to have to watch yourself to find out! But I will say this... If you're someone trying to start a successful online business, this video is a MUST WATCH. I'm serious... I've never seen anything quite like what's revealed in this video. So take a few minutes out of your and watch the "Grandma Video" right away http://tvc.in/2vp3l

    http://jtayl.me/4nw13

    February 9, 2021 at 04:56 | Report abuse | Reply
  13. Drive-20000 Google-Organic-Visitors

    500000 Scrapebox Blast Live SEO blog Comment Backlinks: https://www.seoclerk.com/Link-Building/842132/500000-Scrapebox-Blast-Live-SEO-blog-Comment-Backlinks

    https://www.seoclerk.com/user/jackpower99

    February 16, 2021 at 09:52 | Report abuse | Reply
  14. https://thuocladientu123.com

    Best view i have ever seen !

    https://images.google.ge/url?q=https://thuocladientu123.com

    February 26, 2021 at 15:12 | Report abuse | Reply
  15. https://shiatsu-web.com

    Best view i have ever seen !

    https://maps.google.com.pg/url?q=https://shiatsu-web.com

    March 2, 2021 at 21:32 | Report abuse | Reply
  16. Maryann Schildt

    I really like your writing style, excellent information, appreciate it for posting :D. "If a cluttered desk is the sign of a cluttered mind, what is the significance of a clean desk" by Laurence J. Peter.

    https://www.electricpercolatorcoffeepot.com/10-top-coffee-bloggers/

    March 4, 2021 at 10:04 | Report abuse | Reply
  17. Marvella Wesberry

    You could certainly see your expertise in the work you write. The arena hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who aren't afraid to say how they believe. Always go after your heart. "Everyone has his day and some days last longer than others." by Sir Winston Leonard Spenser Churchill.

    https://www.electricpercolatorcoffeepot.com/10-top-coffee-bloggers/

    March 6, 2021 at 14:05 | Report abuse | Reply
  18. kocioł parowy

    439515 537917Aw, this was a truly good post. In concept I wish to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make an outstanding article nevertheless what can I say I procrastinate alot and not at all appear to get something done. 188458

    March 8, 2021 at 11:17 | Report abuse | Reply
  19. Carrolxnq

    pick online dating service personals strategies for Men topics indicated

    online dating service personals with regard to Men which can Increase your odds of SuccessIn this kind of we can discuss some successful men. the following tips will likely for huge aide you to though it is true matchmaking each and every daughter. based on them, have tried nearly all thing and are not any interested in acquiring it romance. to suit going each and every one it needs is considered completely correct connected limited most important directs. despite the fact that, auto feelings is a crucial thing, even though you should always be also handling wide variety of stuff along with relationship these folks virtual. extra 5 online dating service personals details with regard to online marketers who is merely starting out. know what you have to do to attract sweltering ladies online by sorting out this type of 4 online dating site regarding men. acknowledge what you ought to do to draw burning young women online by considering these 4 uniform dating with regard to men. youth timepiece fantastic online dating opportunities on their best the television route to operate using the advice whenever her within the web. in the instance everyone completely grasp his or her relevance and have a look at all-important tasks to understand escort lesson well, They can remain confident that they can be successful of these personals. I wager you asked yourself in those types of factors is wonderful for you. They may not care either sell your home. It will depend on any type of female patient in order to relationship, though. Whoop dee deliver. nobody care about anything but the graphics. But a fraction of the reasons continue to be so obvious that they won't be brushed aside. One asiame.com must fully accept the wants or the finish reason of the international dating right before they visit added.

    April 16, 2021 at 21:44 | Report abuse | Reply
1 2 3

Leave a Reply to Maryann Schildt


 

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.

Advertisement
About this blog

Get a behind-the-scenes look at the latest stories from CNN Chief Medical Correspondent, Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Senior Medical Correspondent Elizabeth Cohen and the CNN Medical Unit producers. They'll share news and views on health and medical trends - info that will help you take better care of yourself and the people you love.