November 8th, 2010
12:01 AM ET
Topical rub eases kids' cold symptoms, study says
Although Vicks VapoRub is often used to fight colds and congestion, there has never been proof of how well it works. Now, new research reported in the journal Pediatrics finds, the combination of camphor, menthol and eucalyptus oils actually does ease cold symptoms and help children suffering from upper-respiratory infections sleep.
In the study, funded by an unrestricted research grant from Procter & Gamble, makers of Vicks, researchers took 138 children between the ages of 2 and 11, with symptoms like cough, congestion, runny nose and restless sleep that lasted seven days or more. Only children with moderate cough and severe stuffy nose were eligible, and those were divided into three groups.
Some were treated with Vicks, some with a placebo consisting of petroleum jelly and others got no treatment at all. Parents were surveyed the day before treatment about the severity of their child's symptoms. That night, 30 minutes before bedtime, Vicks or petroleum jelly was rubbed onto the child's chest and neck. The next day parents were questioned about their child's symptoms overnight.
Children in all three groups got better, but those treated with the VapoRub saw the greatest improvement, and parents in this group also had improved sleep, the study found.
"The American Academy of Pediatrics says the currently available oral cough and cold medications are not effective for children and have the potential for side effects, " said Dr. Ian Paul, principal investigator and associate professor of pediatrics and public health sciences, Penn State College of Medicine. "This was based in part on some of the studies that we have conducted at Penn State. The current study shows that Vaporub is more effective than placebo."
Paul is on Procter & Gamble's advisory board but holds no stock in the company and will not profit financially.
Where's the line between research and marketing?
Twenty of the 44 children in the vapor rub group suffered mild side effects including skin irritation and burning sensation of the eyes and nose. There were no side effects in the two other groups.
Dr. Jennifer Shu, a practicing pediatrician and CNNHealth's Living Well expert, uses Vicks for her family. "I have found that when used properly it can be a good option for parents who want to relieve some cold symptoms in their children. Parents get frustrated with the FDA recommendations not to use cold medicines in kids under the age of 4 because they are left with few options. Vicks is used topically on the skin, it's not ingested and is not included in these FDA guidelines."
Shu says when used properly, Vicks appears to be safe. But as with any product, parents need to read the instructions carefully and keep medicines out of the reach of children. Vicks VapoRub is not recommend for children under the age of 2.
soundoff (385 Responses)« Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next »
Leave a Reply to Trenton Nerpio
About this blog
Get a behind-the-scenes look at the latest stories from CNN Chief Medical Correspondent, Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Senior Medical Correspondent Elizabeth Cohen and the CNN Medical Unit producers. They'll share news and views on health and medical trends - info that will help you take better care of yourself and the people you love.
cialis price compare http://rcialisgl.com/ cialis overnight delivery
la differenza tra viagra e cialis https://llviagra.com/ viagra einnehmen
where to buy female viagra http://jokviagra.com/ viagra history
erectile https://pharmacylo.com/ canadapharmacy24h
Amoxil https://xlnpharmacy.com/ online drug store
buy cialis with dapoxetine https://cialisee.com/ purchase generic cialis
canada viagra http://pharmacylo.com/ onlinepharmacytabs24 com
taking viagra 100mg [url=https://llviagra.com/ ]best viagra in uk[/url] viagra prices in pakistan
brimonidine dosage generic combigan
buy real cialis on line us with american express florida [url=http://ucialisdas.com/ ]viragecialis[/url] cialis super active
buying viagra online [url=https://jokviagra.com/ ]can women take viagra[/url] roman viagra review
pharmacy online prescription [url=http://xlnpharmacy.com/ ]online pharmacy birth control pills[/url] Tadacip
Cyclomune eye drops 0.05% buy cyclosporine uk
buy cialis tadalafil cost in canada tadalafil cost walmart tadalafil generic where to buy [url=https://tadalafilol.com/ ]where to buy tadalafil on line [/url]
cialis without persciction [url=http://ucialisdas.com/ ]cialis 20 mg best price[/url] buy cialis with paypal payment
cost tadalafil generic https://tadagatadalafil.com/ cialis without prescription cialis without prescription tadalafil online
indian pharmacy online [url=https://pharmacyken.com/ ]Augmentin[/url] vipps certified canadian pharmacies
health canada recall drugs [url=https://cjepharmacy.com/ ]canada drugs coupon[/url] fry's food store pharmacy hours
cialis generic [url=https://ckacialis.com/ ]does generic cialis work?[/url] cialis 20 mg cost
cialis and depoxitine [url=https://ckacialis.com/ ]cialis online paypal[/url] brand cialis in the us
cost of cialis tadalafil price walmart tadalafil online https://tadagatadalafil.com/
cipa approved canadian pharmacies [url=https://pharmacyhrn.com/ ]which canadian pharmacies are legitimate[/url] northwest pharmacy canada reviews
https://tadagatadalafil.com/ generic cialis online fast shipping tadalafil online tadalafil tadalafil generic where to buy
french online pharmacy [url=https://cjepharmacy.com/ ]pharmacy tech certification online[/url] discount drugs online pharmacy
cialis sublingual absorption [url=https://krocialis.com/ ]cialis peak[/url] homemade cialis
can you buy cialis over the counter in canada [url=https://cialishav.com/ ]buy cheap cialis[/url] buying cialis in tijuana
buy generic cialis generic cialis [url=https://cialisjla.com/ ]cialis paypall[/url] viagra cialis sample pack
canadianpharmacy [url=https://pharmacyken.com/ ]Depakote[/url] walgreen pharmacy online
cialis online reddit [url=https://krocialis.com/ ]viagra or cialis which is better[/url] iron dragon cialis
cialis цена [url=https://cialishav.com/ ]cialis after prostate surgery[/url] cialis how long before
genric cialis [url=https://rcialisgl.com/ ]order cialis online without prescription[/url] generic cialis black 800 mg
cialis prices at walmart [url=https://cialisjla.com/ ]cialis tabs[/url] generic cialis overnight delivery
brazilian pharmacy online [url=https://pharmacyhrn.com/ ]legitscript canadian pharmacy[/url] can you buy prescription drugs online without
cialis withdrawal symptoms [url=https://rcialisgl.com/ ]inexpensive real cialis[/url] cialis pill
target pharmacy online refills [url=https://pharmacyken.com/ ]good rx pharmacy discount card[/url] canadian on line pharmacy
walmart store hours pharmacy [url=https://cjepharmacy.com/ ]how long do prescription drugs stay in your system[/url] zanax online pharmacy
order cialis 20mg [url=https://ckacialis.com/ ]cialis los angeles[/url] brand cialis us
medplus pharmacy store locator [url=https://pharmacyhrn.com/ ]online medicine order discount[/url] erectile dysfunction treatment
tadalafil cialis bestprice [url=https://ckacialis.com/ ]cialis without prescriptions uk[/url] cialis softtabs online
donate prescription drugs [url=https://cjepharmacy.com/ ]cialis 5mg canada pharmacy[/url] canadian-pharmacy-24h.com
cialis samples online [url=https://krocialis.com/ ]cialis profesional vs. super active vs. cialis[/url] cialis tadalafil 5mg
how can i buy cialis online [url=https://krocialis.com/ ]cialis online overnight delivery[/url] cialis without a rx
cialis cheap buy [url=https://cialishav.com/ ]best price for cialis 20 mg[/url] cialis egypt
cialis one a day with dapoxetine canada [url=https://cialisjla.com/ ]cialis with dapoxetine[/url] cialis south africa
reliable canadian pharmacy [url=https://pharmacyken.com/ ]texas rx pharmacy[/url] how to buy prescription drugs from canadian pharmacy
777235 342525I dugg some of you post as I thought they were handy quite valuable 7176
cialis sex [url=https://rcialisgl.com/ ]health plus cialis[/url] generic cialis coupon
purchase peptides tadalafil cialis generic tadalafil vs cialis reviews
cialis for sale in canada [url=https://cialishav.com/ ]cialis online australia[/url] can you break 20mg cialis in half
taladafil buy generic cialis online with mastercard tadalafil e20 pill